“Our companies can’t compete with them now because our currency is too strong. And it’s killing us,” Trump told The Journal, referring to competition from China.
The Trump Administration wants to make America great again by transforming it into a manufacturing powerhouse like it was in the Post War glory days. Buy America, hire America. That’s not so bad really. Most Americans are generally on board with this patriotic slogan as long as its implications stop there. But then Mr. Trump takes things a step further with nonsense about the “strong dollar killing us.” By “us,” he means the 13% of the US economy reliant upon goods exports (as opposed to the other 87% more reliant upon domestic services and consumption). Mr. Trump surely isn’t referring to the more than 97% of Americans whose incomes are gained in dollars and whose spending power declines when the dollar’s does.
It is true that, in the near term, sharp increases in the dollar’s value can cause financial instability as foreign debtors struggle to pay back loans denominated in a strengthening currency relative to their own. It also causes the perception of lower US multinational corporate earnings as a portion of overseas earnings in relatively weaker currencies get converted back into stronger dollars at a lower nominal value on the income statement. This is as much a perception as anything because the same relatively stronger dollars that make foreign earnings look lower also have more purchasing power to lower future costs in those same regions.
In the medium to long term, there is absolutely no doubt that a strong domestic currency is in the interest of not just the citizens sharing it, but real GDP as well. Inflation tends to be lower, real incomes tend to be higher, and overall well-being tends to be notably higher in countries with strong currencies and low inflation. This fact has also been the stance of the United States Treasury for several decades. Is Mr. Trump challenging this stance or is he simply using fighting words to get in front of China (or others potentially) before it might need to devalue the yuan? Does he want to be able to say “told you so” if and when the yuan gets devalued with the intention of gaining enough political capital to impose tariffs against China? Who knows. It isn’t heartening that Mr. Trump doesn’t seem to understand how China is actually burning through currency reserves to prop up the value of its currency rather than hold it down as he alleges.
It comes down to this: will market sentiment return to favoring the dollar when US economic data surpasses expectations or have Trump Administration words materially damaged the perception of the long standing King Dollar policy in a way that it outweighs the data? Assist FX sees a continuation of data dependent sentiment for the dollar unless the Trump Administration makes an official move to target “currency manipulation” of trading partners using an executive order or proposed legislation. Markets are hyper-sensitive to Trump Administration commentary right now given all of the actions taken already in the first couple of weeks of its existence but the data will eventually move back into the driver’s seat.